Quick answer
Employees pay tax and NI through PAYE and cannot claim most expenses, while the self-employed pay through Self Assessment and can deduct business costs but have fewer employment rights.
Filing your Self Assessment doesn’t have to be stressful. Let our qualified accountants handle everything — accurately and on time.
How tax is collected
Employers deduct income tax and NI from wages. Sole traders calculate and pay their own tax through Self Assessment.
Expenses
Self-employed people claim costs that are wholly for business. Employees can usually claim only a few expenses, such as some uniform costs.
Want an accountant to handle this for you?
Fixed price from £199 + VAT. Done for you online by UK accountants.
Order online now See our Self Assessment for sole traders service
National Insurance
Employees pay Class 1 NI. The self-employed pay Class 4 NI and may pay Class 2 voluntarily.
Rights and benefits
Employees get holiday pay, sick pay and pensions through work. The self-employed need to plan their own protection and retirement savings.
How the tax is collected
The biggest day-to-day difference is the way tax is paid. An employee has income tax and National Insurance deducted by their employer through PAYE every payday, using the tax code HMRC supplies. The money has usually gone before it reaches the bank account, and for many employees there is no return to file at all. A self-employed person receives their income gross and must calculate tax themselves, register for Self Assessment, file a return and pay the bill on set dates. Those dates are 31 January for the balancing payment and first payment on account, and 31 July for the second payment on account if payments on account apply. Our guide to tax codes shows how employees’ deductions are set.
National Insurance and what it buys
Employees pay Class 1 National Insurance through payroll, currently 8% on earnings between £12,570 and £50,270, and 2% above that. Check current HMRC guidance for the rates in force. The self-employed pay Class 4 on profits instead, at 6% between £12,570 and £50,270 and 2% above. Compulsory Class 2 was abolished in April 2024. If your profit is at or above the Small Profits Threshold of £6,845, you are treated as having paid Class 2 for state pension credit purposes, and below that you can choose to pay voluntary Class 2 to protect your entitlement. For more, read Class 4 National Insurance explained and whether Class 2 is still payable.
Worked example: £40,000 earned two ways
This is an illustrative example in England, ignoring pensions, student loans and any employer-side costs. Compare an employee on a £40,000 salary with a sole trader making £40,000 profit after expenses.
| Employee | Self-employed | |
|---|---|---|
| Income above £12,570 | £27,430 | £27,430 |
| Income tax at 20% | £5,486.00 | £5,486.00 |
| National Insurance | £27,430 x 8% = £2,194.40 | £27,430 x 6% = £1,645.80 |
| Total deductions | £7,680.40 | £7,131.80 |
The self-employed person pays £548.60 less in this example. It is not the full picture. The employee also receives paid holiday, sick pay, employer pension contributions and other protections, while the self-employed person has none of these and must fund them from profit. The sole trader can deduct allowable expenses, which may lower profit, but they also take on the cost of equipment, insurance and the risk of quiet periods.
Other differences worth knowing
Expenses
Self-employed people deduct business expenses from profit. Employees can claim only a narrow set of costs that are incurred wholly, exclusively and necessarily for their work, so claims are much less common.
Registering and records
You must register for Self Assessment by 5 October after the end of the tax year in which you start trading. You need to keep your records for five years after the 31 January deadline. See our first-year self-employed guide for the steps.
Common mistakes
- Spending all the money received without setting tax aside.
- Forgetting to register within the deadline.
- Assuming employment status can be chosen freely. It depends on the facts of the working relationship.
- Comparing take-home pay without including holiday pay, sick pay and pension.
- Not accounting for payments on account in the first year.
- Failing to tell HMRC when you have both employed and self-employed income.
Practical checklist
- Check whether you are genuinely self-employed or an employee for tax purposes.
- Register for Self Assessment if you are starting out.
- Open a separate account for business money.
- Set aside a share of every payment. See saving for your tax bill.
- Keep records of income and expenses.
- Review each year whether your arrangement still suits you.
How SATR can help
If you have both employment and self-employed income, our qualified UK accountants can pull the figures together and file online, for a fixed fee from £199 + VAT. See our Self Assessment service for sole traders.
This is general information, not personal tax advice.
Moving from employment to self-employment
Many people make the change gradually, keeping a job while building a business on the side. That route has real advantages. You can test demand, build a client base and learn how your records need to look before relying on the business for all your income. The sensible steps are to keep your employer informed where your contract requires it, register for Self Assessment once your trading begins, and open a separate bank account. If you do leave employment, ask your employer for your P45 and keep it safely, because you may need it for your return. Also review your pension arrangements, as you will lose employer contributions and need to decide how much to pay into a personal pension yourself. The first year usually involves the most learning, so allow extra time for the first return, and expect the first January bill to include a payment on account on top of the tax for the year.
Frequently asked questions
Can I be both employed and self-employed?
Yes, many people have a job and side business and report both.
Which pays less tax?
It depends on income, expenses and profits, so compare with an accountant.
Tax rules and rates change. Figures here reflect 2025/26 guidance; always check current HMRC rules or ask us before acting.
Can I be employed and self-employed at the same time?
Yes. Many people have a job and a side business. You will need to register for Self Assessment and report both, with PAYE covering your employment income and a separate bill for the self-employed profit.
Do the self-employed get sick pay or holiday pay?
No. Self-employed people do not receive employment rights like sick or holiday pay from clients, so these need to be planned for from profits or through insurance.
Which is better for tax, being employed or self-employed?
It depends on the circumstances. Lower National Insurance can make self-employment cheaper, but benefits and security differ, and the correct status depends on the facts of the work, not personal preference.
Don’t leave your tax return to the last minute. Avoid penalties, save time, and let an expert take care of it for you.
Related guides
- VAT Registration for Sole Traders: The £90,000 Threshold
- Basis Period Reform: What Changed for Self-Employed Tax Years
- Partnership Tax Returns: SA800 and Partner Self Assessment
- Self Assessment for sole traders
Ready to file without the stress?
Fixed price from £199 + VAT. Done for you online by UK accountants.
Order online now See our Self Assessment for sole traders service
{“@context”:”https://schema.org”,”@type”:”FAQPage”,”mainEntity”:[{“@type”:”Question”,”name”:”Can I be both employed and self-employed?”,”acceptedAnswer”:{“@type”:”Answer”,”text”:”Yes, many people have a job and side business and report both.”}},{“@type”:”Question”,”name”:”Which pays less tax?”,”acceptedAnswer”:{“@type”:”Answer”,”text”:”It depends on income, expenses and profits, so compare with an accountant.”}},{“@type”:”Question”,”name”:”Can I be employed and self-employed at the same time?”,”acceptedAnswer”:{“@type”:”Answer”,”text”:”Yes. Many people have a job and a side business. You will need to register for Self Assessment and report both, with PAYE covering your employment income and a separate bill for the self-employed profit.”}},{“@type”:”Question”,”name”:”Do the self-employed get sick pay or holiday pay?”,”acceptedAnswer”:{“@type”:”Answer”,”text”:”No. Self-employed people do not receive employment rights like sick or holiday pay from clients, so these need to be planned for from profits or through insurance.”}},{“@type”:”Question”,”name”:”Which is better for tax, being employed or self-employed?”,”acceptedAnswer”:{“@type”:”Answer”,”text”:”It depends on the circumstances. Lower National Insurance can make self-employment cheaper, but benefits and security differ, and the correct status depends on the facts of the work, not personal preference.”}}]}





