Self Assessment guide

10 Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Self Assessment Accountant

Table of Contents

Quick answer

Ask about qualifications, fixed fees, what is included, who prepares your return and how they handle deadlines, queries and HMRC letters before you commit.

We Handle Your Tax Return For You

Filing your Self Assessment doesn’t have to be stressful. Let our qualified accountants handle everything — accurately and on time.

Qualifications and regulation

Ask whether they are ICAEW, ACCA or AAT qualified or regulated, and whether they hold professional indemnity insurance.

Fees and what is included

Ask for a fixed fee in writing, and whether it covers bookkeeping review, expense checks, HMRC letters and amendments.

Want an accountant to handle this for you?

Fixed price from £199 + VAT. Done for you online by UK accountants.

Order online now See our Self Assessment pricing service

Process and communication

Ask how information is sent, who prepares and who reviews your return and how quickly they respond to questions.

Deadlines and support

Ask when they need your records, whether they file early and what happens if HMRC writes to you after filing.

Why the choice of accountant matters

Your Self Assessment return is a legal declaration, and the person who prepares it affects how accurate it is, whether deadlines are met and how well you are supported if HMRC raises questions. A cheap quote that leaves out half the work can end up costing more than a clear fixed fee, and an accountant who is not properly authorised cannot deal with HMRC for you at all. A few well-chosen questions before you sign up will protect you from the most common disappointments.

Questions about credentials and safeguards

  • Are you qualified, and with which professional body? Ask for the body and membership details, and check them on the body’s own public register where one exists. Qualification varies, and the term accountant itself is not protected, so it is worth checking.
  • Are you registered for anti-money laundering supervision? Accountancy firms in the UK are required to be supervised.
  • Do you hold professional indemnity insurance? This protects you if the firm makes an error.
  • Will you be authorised to act as my agent with HMRC? You will normally need to authorise them, and you can check and cancel the authorisation later.
  • How do you handle my data? Ask where documents are stored and who can see them.

Questions about price and scope

  • Is the fee fixed, and does it include VAT? If you are not VAT registered, the VAT-inclusive price is your real cost.
  • What is included? Check whether property pages, capital gains, CIS, foreign income or a second tax year are extra.
  • What happens if I send documents late, or have extra questions?
  • Will you tell me the amount due, and by when? Make sure the quote covers the 31 January payment calculation and any payments on account.
  • Do you support me if HMRC opens an enquiry? Many firms charge separately, so ask first. See what to do if HMRC opens an enquiry.

Worked example: comparing three quotes

This is an illustrative example using made-up firms, for a sole trader who also has one rental property and is not VAT registered.

Firm How it is priced Net VAT at 20% Total to you
Firm A Fixed fee, rental pages included £199 £39.80 £238.80
Firm B Base £150 + £75 property pages + £50 sole trader pages £275 £55.00 £330.00
Firm C Hourly, 4 hours at £90 £360 £72.00 £432.00

The firm with the lowest headline price is not the cheapest once add-ons and VAT are included, and the hourly firm can rise further if the work takes longer than planned. The aim is to compare like with like, so ask each firm to confirm in writing exactly what its price covers. This is not a comparison of any real firm’s prices.

Practical considerations before you sign

Timing and communication

Ask how and when you will hear from the firm, and what the cut-off date for sending documents is. The key dates are 5 October for registration, 31 October for paper returns and 31 January for online returns and payment. Our guides on the filing deadline and reasons to file early explain why early preparation helps. You should also know what you need to supply, which our guide to Self Assessment documents lists.

Your own responsibilities

An accountant prepares the return based on what you tell them, but the legal responsibility for the return stays with you. Give complete and honest information, keep your records for five years after the 31 January deadline, and read the return before it is submitted.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing on price alone without checking what is included.
  • Not checking qualifications or insurance.
  • Leaving the decision until January and rushing.
  • Assuming the accountant will chase missing records for you.
  • Not keeping a copy of the submitted return and the calculation.

Practical checklist

  1. Ask for the firm’s qualifications and supervision details.
  2. Get a written scope of work and fee, including VAT.
  3. Confirm the document deadline.
  4. Check how HMRC authorisation works.
  5. Ask what is included if HMRC makes an enquiry.

How SATR can help

SATR, a trading style of Accotax, offers a fixed fee from £199 + VAT with qualified UK accountants and online filing, so you know the cost upfront. See Self Assessment for sole traders or order online.

This article is general information, not personal tax advice.

Red flags to watch for

Some warning signs are worth taking seriously. Be wary of anyone who promises a guaranteed refund before seeing your figures, who suggests you leave income off the return, or who asks you to sign a blank or incomplete return. Avoid firms that will not put their fee and scope in writing, that cannot explain who is actually preparing your return, or that are vague about how they will be authorised to deal with HMRC. You should also be cautious about arrangements that seem too good to be true, such as schemes that claim to cut your tax to almost nothing; the safest approach is to ask for the legal basis of any tax-saving suggestion and to check current HMRC guidance. A reputable accountant will be happy to explain their work and will ask you plenty of questions in return. If you receive confusing letters afterwards, our guide to HMRC letters explained is a useful companion.

Frequently asked questions

Should I choose the cheapest accountant?

Not necessarily. Compare qualifications, scope and service, not just price.

Can I switch accountants mid-year?

Yes, ask your new accountant to handle the professional clearance with the old one.

Tax rules and rates change. Figures here reflect 2025/26 guidance; always check current HMRC rules or ask us before acting.

Does an accountant take responsibility if my return is wrong?

The legal responsibility for the return stays with you. A good accountant should prepare it carefully and, if they hold professional indemnity insurance, there is a route for claims about their errors.

Is the cheapest accountant the best choice?

Not necessarily. Compare what is included, qualifications, insurance and support, rather than just the headline price.

When should I appoint an accountant?

As early as possible, ideally soon after the tax year ends on 5 April, so there is time to gather records before the 31 January deadline.

Leave Your Tax Return To The Experts

Don’t leave your tax return to the last minute. Avoid penalties, save time, and let an expert take care of it for you.

Related guides

Ready to file without the stress?

Fixed price from £199 + VAT. Done for you online by UK accountants.

Order online now See our Self Assessment pricing service

Not sure where to start? Let us file it for you.

SATR is a trading style of Accotax. Our qualified UK accountants prepare and file your Self Assessment return online for a fixed fee, so you never miss a deadline or overpay tax.

Self Assessment tax return

From £199 + VAT

  • Prepared and filed by an accountant
  • Maximise your expenses and reliefs
  • Fixed fee, pay online, no surprises
  • HMRC deadline reminders

Questions? Call 0203 4411 258
★★★★★ Rated Excellent on Google

Stop worrying about HMRC. Let an accountant file for you.

Fixed fee from £199 + VAT. Pay online, send your details and let our qualified accountants do the rest.

More Self Assessment guides

Scroll to Top